The Akron Press Club luncheon held on July 26 was well-attended, with plenty of audience questions and coverage by local news organizations. Read key takeaways below and find links to the full news articles.
Summa-HATCo deal observers dive into questions about financing for-profit hospital model
- Patrick Williams, Akron Beacon Journal
Click to read article
Key takeaways: The Akron Press Club event featured an in-depth discussion on the Summa Health and HATCo deal, focusing on its financial implications and prospects. Paul Lee from Strategic Health Care highlighted the strategic necessity of Summa’s shift to a for-profit model under HATCo, driven by severe financial struggles and substantial debt. J.B. Silvers from Case Western Reserve University emphasized that while for-profit and nonprofit hospitals operate differently, the shift will significantly impact Summa’s community obligations and tax contributions. The discussion, moderated by M.L. Schultze, revealed that HATCo's goals include leveraging new technologies like AI to enhance operational efficiencies rather than stripping assets. Summa CEO Dr. Cliff Deveny assured that General Catalyst’s profit expectations are modest, aiming for a 1-2% return, and stressed their commitment to innovation in healthcare services. Despite the risks associated with the competitive tech landscape and low Medicare reimbursements, experts believe Summa’s transition will focus on expanding outpatient services and integrating advanced technologies to improve healthcare delivery.
Industry experts anticipate hurdles for Summa Health's new buyer
- Taylor Wizner, Ideastream Public Media
Click to read article
Key takeaways: Health care industry analysts expressed skepticism about the venture capital firm HATCo's plan to acquire Summa Health. Paul Lee of Strategic Health Care cautioned that significant profits from new technology and efficiencies are essential for the system's success, a challenge many for-profits have struggled with over the past decade. J.B. Silvers from Case Western Reserve University acknowledged the theoretical benefits of the deal, such as new tax revenue, a community foundation, and financial sustainability, but remained uncertain about the profitability of HATCo’s technological innovations. Residents voiced concerns to Summa CEO Dr. Cliff Deveny about potential service cuts and a focus on wealthier patients under for-profit ownership. The experts noted mixed outcomes for patient care in for-profit hospitals nationally, citing the recent bankruptcy of Steward Healthcare. Despite these concerns, Deveny anticipates the deal will be finalized by year-end.
Summa Health acquisition: Experts debate potential sale to private equity firm
– Andrew Keiper, SignalAkron.org
Click to read article
Key takeaways: Experts debated the proposed acquisition of Summa Health by private equity firm HATco, weighing its potential impact on Akron and the hospital's patients. J.B. Silvers from Case Western Reserve University expressed optimism, highlighting the benefits of debt clearance, new technologies, and the creation of a community foundation from the sale's proceeds. He described these elements as a "trifecta" for success. In contrast, Paul Lee of Strategic Healthcare voiced caution, noting the challenges private equity firms face in balancing profit motives with community healthcare needs. He questioned the sustainability of maintaining non-profitable services and the potential long-term impacts on care quality. Both experts acknowledged the promise of technological advancements, with Silvers emphasizing that HATco's profitability would stem from successfully implementing and selling these innovations beyond Summa. The discussion also touched on HATco’s commitment to retaining Summa's nearly 9,000 employees, a reassuring move for the hospital staff amid the pending sale.